Blog › Article

Why is my car overheating? Common causes and what to check

By the ImportRepairCost team · Oct 15, 2026 · 4 min read

What to do right away when your temperature gauge climbs, the most common reasons cars overheat, and what you can safely check yourself.

A temperature gauge creeping toward hot, or a red coolant warning on the dash, is one of the warnings you should never ignore. An engine that keeps running while it overheats can warp its cylinder head, blow a head gasket, or seize. A repair that might have been a few hundred dollars can turn into an engine replacement.

Here's what to do in the moment, the most common causes, and what you can safely check yourself.

What to do right away

  1. Turn off the A/C. It adds load to the engine and heat to the radiator.
  2. Turn the heater to full hot and the fan to high. It feels backwards, but your heater core is a small radiator. Running it pulls some heat away from the engine.
  3. Pull over as soon as it's safe and shut the engine off. If the gauge is in the red or the warning light is on, don't keep driving to "make it home."
  4. Don't open the hood right away if you see steam pouring out. Give it a few minutes.
  5. Call for a tow if you're not sure. A tow is cheap compared with a damaged engine.

Safety first: never open a hot radiator cap

The cooling system runs under pressure, and that pressure lets coolant get hotter than boiling without turning to steam. If you open the radiator cap or the expansion tank cap on a hot engine, that pressure is released all at once. Scalding coolant and steam can spray out and cause serious burns.

The most common causes

Low coolant from a leak

This is the most common cause. Coolant can leak from hoses, the radiator, the water pump, or a cracked plastic expansion tank or fitting. Plastic cooling parts are common on many European cars and get brittle with age and heat. Signs include a sweet smell, puddles that are green, pink, orange, or blue, and crusty residue around hoses and fittings.

A thermostat stuck closed

The thermostat controls when coolant flows to the radiator. If it sticks closed, the engine can overheat quickly, often while the radiator itself still feels cool. Thermostats are a common wear item and are often replaced along with a water pump.

A failing water pump

The water pump moves coolant through the engine. Pumps can leak from their seal or simply stop moving enough coolant. Some engines, including BMW's N54, use an electric water pump that can fail with little warning. Owners have reported what they paid to replace the BMW N54 electric water pump and thermostat and the VW EA888 Gen 3 water pump and thermostat housing.

Cooling fan problems

If your car overheats mostly in traffic or at idle but is fine on the highway, suspect the cooling fan. At speed, air moves through the radiator on its own. When you're stopped, the fan has to do that work. A failed fan motor, relay, fuse, sensor, or (on older cars) fan clutch can all cause this pattern.

A clogged or damaged radiator

Over time, radiators can clog inside with deposits or outside with bugs, dirt, and debris. Bent fins and internal clogs both cut cooling capacity.

Air in the cooling system

After any cooling system work, air can get trapped in the system. Many modern cars, especially BMWs, need a specific bleeding procedure to get it out. A car that starts overheating right after a coolant job often just has an air pocket.

A bad radiator or expansion tank cap

The cap keeps the system at the right pressure. A worn seal lets pressure escape, which lowers the boiling point and can let coolant boil away.

Head gasket failure

A failing head gasket can push combustion gases into the coolant, or let coolant leak into the cylinders. Signs include white exhaust smoke with a sweet smell, bubbles in the expansion tank, coolant loss with no visible leak, and milky oil. Some engines are known for it. Subaru's non-turbo EJ25 is a well-known example. See what owners paid for Subaru EJ25 head gaskets.

What you can check yourself (engine cold)

If you top off coolant, use the type your manufacturer specifies. Mixing types can cause problems. Adding plain water in an emergency is better than running dry, but have the mix corrected afterward.

When to stop and get help

If the car has overheated badly, keeps losing coolant, shows signs of a head gasket problem, or overheats again after you top it off, stop driving it and have it inspected. A shop can pressure-test the system to find leaks and test for combustion gases in the coolant. Our guide on how to tell if a repair quote is fair can help when the estimate comes in.

This article is general information for car owners. It is not a substitute for a diagnosis by a qualified mechanic who can inspect your car. Prices mentioned are medians of owner reports, not quotes.

More from the blog

Oct 19, 2026 · 4 min readWhy your 100k-mile maintenance mattersWhat usually comes due around 100,000 miles on import and enthusiast cars, why it matters, and how to plan for it without overpaying.Read article →Oct 11, 2026 · 4 min readTiming belt vs timing chain: what's the difference and why it mattersHow timing belts and timing chains work, how long each lasts, the warning signs to watch for, and what that means for your maintenance budget.Read article →Oct 7, 2026 · 4 min readWhat is carbon buildup on direct-injection engines?Why direct-injection engines like many Audi, VW, BMW and MINI engines build up carbon on their intake valves, the symptoms, how it's cleaned, and what it costs.Read article →
The Indie Wrench: a weekly email with real repair prices from independent import shops. Join the list